news.volyx.in

Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit (blog.comma.ai)

1212 points by arduinomancer · 1477 days ago · 299 comments on HN

Article summary

Comma.ai, a company founded by George Hotz, is being sued by Axel Nix, a patent troll, over a 15-year-old patent for an auto emergency call system. Hotz plans to fight the lawsuit and invalidate the patent, rather than settling. The patent troll has previously sued other companies in the autonomous vehicle industry, with some settling out of court. Hotz is inspired by Cloudflare's approach to dealing with patent trolls and plans to work with others to combat the issue.

Main themes

  • patent trolls
  • collective action
  • individual agency
  • legislative reform
  • patent law
  • litigation strategy

What commenters say

  • Fighting patent trolls is more effective than settling, as it can prevent future lawsuits and invalidate bogus patents.
  • Collective action is necessary to combat patent trolls, as individual companies may not have the resources to fight them alone.
  • Individual agency and willingness to take a stand against patent trolls can be an effective deterrent.
  • The current legislative system is broken and unable to effectively reform patent laws to prevent trolling.
  • Some companies, like Newegg and Cloudflare, have successfully fought patent trolls and can serve as models for others.
  • Patent trolls can be deterred if companies are willing to spend money on lawsuits and fight them aggressively.
  • The issue of patent trolls requires a combination of individual and collective action to be effectively addressed.
  • Settling with patent trolls can fuel their business model and encourage further lawsuits.