news.volyx.in

We need a flowchart editor that doesn't give you carpal tunnel (scottantipa.com)

486 points by escot · 1546 days ago · 185 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the need for a flowchart editor that is efficient and easy to use, without causing physical strain. The author is creating a tool called Knotend, which uses a keyboard-centric interface and a 2D grid to simplify the process of creating flowcharts. The goal is to make it feel like a text editor, rather than a graphical mess of boxes and arrows. Knotend is designed to be fast and intuitive, allowing users to focus on defining dependencies between tasks.

Main themes

  • flowchart editors
  • ergonomics and usability
  • graph layout algorithms
  • keyboard-centric interfaces
  • project management tools
  • textual representations of flowcharts

What commenters say

  • Some users find Knotend to be a promising solution for creating flowcharts quickly and easily, but suggest improvements such as better support for mobile devices.
  • Others prefer existing tools like Mermaid or PlantUML, which offer textual representations of flowcharts and can be more flexible.
  • There is disagreement about the use of keyboard shortcuts in Knotend, with some finding them intuitive and others suggesting alternative approaches.
  • The discussion highlights the challenges of creating effective graph layout algorithms and the trade-offs between automated layout and manual control.
  • Some commenters note that gaming and other applications may have different ergonomic considerations than flowchart editing, and that individual preferences play a significant role.
  • The importance of dependency graphs in project management and the need for better tools to support them is a recurring theme.
  • There are differing opinions on the suitability of Knotend for complex flowcharts, with some seeing it as a useful tool for simple cases and others wanting more advanced features.