news.volyx.in

Google cancelled a talk on caste bias (washingtonpost.com)

760 points by devnonymous · 1564 days ago · 946 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses Google cancelling a talk on caste bias. The comments reveal that the talk was proposed by mid-level employees but blocked by high-level ones. The incident sparks a discussion on social justice and diversity in the tech industry. The conversation also touches on sexism and discrimination in the workplace.

Main themes

  • caste bias
  • sexism in tech
  • diversity and inclusion
  • cultural bias
  • discrimination in the workplace
  • gender disparities in tech jobs

What commenters say

  • Some argue that women are discriminated against in the job market, with evidence from studies showing they are paid less and have lower-paying jobs.
  • Others claim that anecdotal evidence is insufficient to prove discrimination, and more rigorous studies are needed to support such claims.
  • The disparity in the number of women in QA jobs compared to other tech jobs may be a symptom of cultural bias, but the reasons for this disparity are unclear.
  • It is suggested that the goal should be to remove bias and prejudice that hurts certain categories of people, but others question whether this is a problem that needs to be addressed.
  • Some believe that men and women may have natural different dispositions to work in certain fields, and that striving for balance may not be necessary or desirable.
  • The idea that cultural bias is the primary cause of gender disparities is disputed, with some arguing that it is impossible to control for all parameters and prove this claim.
  • Others argue that the fact that gender disparities are changing quickly and differ from country to country suggests that cultural bias is a significant factor.
  • The conversation highlights the complexity of issues surrounding diversity and inclusion in the tech industry, with different perspectives on the nature of the problems and the best ways to address them.