news.volyx.in

T-Mobile begins blocking iPhone users from enabling iCloud Private Relay in US (9to5mac.com)

692 points by monocularvision · 1712 days ago · 411 comments on HN

Article summary

T-Mobile has begun blocking iPhone users from enabling iCloud Private Relay in the US, a feature that provides an additional layer of privacy by hiding users' IP addresses and internet activity. This move follows similar actions by some European carriers, who have expressed concerns that Private Relay could impact their ability to manage telecommunication networks. T-Mobile claims that only customers with content filtering enabled, such as parent controls, are affected, but some users have reported being blocked despite not having such features enabled. The blockage can be circumvented by using a custom DNS server or a VPN, but this is not a straightforward process for most users.

Main themes

  • iCloud Private Relay
  • carrier blocking
  • internet privacy
  • network management
  • censorship
  • VPN and DNS workarounds

What commenters say

  • Some carriers are blocking iCloud Private Relay to comply with their own policies or to manage their networks, and Apple has provided a way for them to do so.
  • Blocking Private Relay is a form of censorship that can be used to restrict access to certain content or to monitor users' internet activity.
  • Using a custom DNS server or a VPN can bypass the blockage, but this may not be a viable solution for all users.
  • The ability of carriers to block Private Relay raises concerns about the power of carriers to control and restrict internet access.
  • Some users are considering switching to different carriers that do not block Private Relay, citing the importance of internet freedom and privacy.
  • The blockage of Private Relay may not be uniform across all users and carriers, with some users reporting that they are able to access the feature despite their carrier's policies.
  • The issue highlights the tension between carriers' interests and users' desire for privacy and freedom online.
  • Apple's decision to allow carriers to block Private Relay has been criticized as disappointing and potentially harmful to users' privacy and freedom.