news.volyx.in

My parents collect cans for a living (thenation.com)

452 points by emailed · 1735 days ago · 392 comments on HN

Article summary

The article tells the story of a young person whose parents collect cans and bottles for a living, and how they initially felt ashamed of this fact but eventually came to see it as a source of pride. The author describes their experiences helping their parents with the can collecting and the reactions they received from friends and teachers. The story highlights the importance of hard work and the value of recycling. The author's family benefits from the five-cent deposit on beverage cans in New York State.

Main themes

  • can collecting
  • recycling
  • financial stability
  • low-income families
  • deposit systems
  • labor rights

What commenters say

  • Some people view can collecting as a viable way to make a living, especially in areas with deposit systems.
  • Others see it as a struggle that highlights the need for better financial support for low-income families.
  • The deposit system is considered an effective way to increase recycling rates and reduce litter.
  • Some argue that the deposit amount is too low to make a significant difference in the lives of can collectors.
  • Others believe that increasing the deposit amount could lead to more people collecting cans, but may not necessarily improve their financial stability.
  • The discussion also touches on the broader issue of financial stability for hard workers in the US, with some arguing that it is a problem that needs to be addressed.
  • There are differing opinions on whether the US is doing enough to support low-income families and provide opportunities for financial stability.
  • Some people think that the US should prioritize creating better-paying jobs and providing more support for low-income families, rather than relying on programs like can collecting to supplement their income.