news.volyx.in

Lego has designed a set that can't be taken apart (brickset.com)

663 points by brycehalley · 1752 days ago · 399 comments on HN

Article summary

LEGO has designed a set, 75313 AT-AT, that has some sub-assemblies which cannot be dismantled without using sharp metal implements, going against the traditional LEGO principle of being able to take apart and rebuild models. This issue has been discovered in the set's Technic frames and axles. The problem is seen as a disappointment and a potential oversight in the design process. The set's design has sparked a discussion about the company's focus on creating display pieces rather than playable models.

Main themes

  • LEGO design principles
  • playability vs display
  • quality control
  • adult fan market
  • creativity and building skills
  • electronic instructions and apps
  • complexity and expense of sets
  • community values and expectations

What commenters say

  • The inability to disassemble the set is a major flaw that goes against the core principles of LEGO.
  • The issue is likely a result of human error and a lack of proper quality control.
  • LEGO's focus on creating display pieces for adult fans has led to a shift away from the company's traditional values of playability and creativity.
  • The problem can be solved by redesigning certain parts, such as axles with stops, to make them more easily removable.
  • Some people do not see this as a major issue, as they do not intend to take apart their sets once they are built.
  • The use of electronic instructions and apps is changing the way people interact with LEGO sets, potentially leading to a loss of traditional building skills.
  • The company's move towards more complex and expensive sets has led to a decrease in playability and an increase in sets being used as display pieces.
  • The LEGO community is divided between those who value the ability to take apart and rebuild sets and those who prioritize display and collectibility.