news.volyx.in

Google removes Pirate Bay domains from search results citing Dutch court order (torrentfreak.com)

493 points by XiS · 1753 days ago · 316 comments on HN

Article summary

Google has removed The Pirate Bay and over 100 related domains from its search results in the Netherlands, citing a Dutch court order. The order was issued to Dutch ISPs, but Google chose to comply voluntarily. This move is seen as a significant step in Google's anti-piracy efforts, although the company has previously refused to remove pirate sites from its search results. The removal only affects users with a Dutch IP address.

Main themes

  • piracy and copyright
  • search engine moderation
  • censorship and free speech
  • corporate power and self-regulation
  • intellectual property rights
  • online discourse and accessibility

What commenters say

  • Google's decision to remove The Pirate Bay from its search results sets a dangerous precedent for censorship and moderation of online content.
  • Search engines should not moderate search results, and policing should be done on the actual hosts of the content.
  • Google's move is a pragmatic decision to protect itself from lawsuits and maintain its dominance in the search engine market.
  • The distinction between moderation by prioritization and blacklisting is not clear-cut, and both methods can be seen as forms of censorship.
  • The removal of The Pirate Bay from search results will likely have a significant impact on the site's accessibility and visibility.
  • Some argue that Google's decision is a necessary measure to prevent the spread of pirated content, while others see it as an overreach of corporate power.
  • The issue highlights the complexities of balancing free speech and intellectual property rights in the digital age.
  • Voluntary compliance with court orders can be seen as a form of self-regulation, but it also raises concerns about the role of corporations in shaping online discourse.