news.volyx.in

Microsoft blocks EdgeDeflector to force Windows 11 users into Edge (theverge.com)

885 points by Vinnl · 1768 days ago · 571 comments on HN

Article summary

Microsoft has blocked EdgeDeflector, a third-party app that allowed Windows 11 users to bypass Edge and use their default browser for Start menu search results. This move is seen as an attempt to force users into using Edge, despite Microsoft's claims that Windows offers an open platform for various web browsers. The block is part of an upcoming Windows 11 update and has been met with criticism from developers and users. Microsoft's actions have raised concerns about the company's prioritization of its own products over user choice.

Main themes

  • Microsoft's anti-competitive behavior
  • Browser choice and user freedom
  • Edge and Bing promotion
  • Windows 11 updates and features
  • Data collection and privacy
  • Alternative browsers and operating systems
  • Microsoft's business strategy and priorities

What commenters say

  • Microsoft's actions are seen as anti-competitive and reminiscent of their past legal troubles with Internet Explorer.
  • The company's decision to block EdgeDeflector is a strategic move to increase Edge's market share and drive users to Bing.
  • Some users argue that Microsoft's behavior is not surprising, given their history of prioritizing their own products over user choice.
  • Others believe that Microsoft's actions are a nuisance, but ultimately, users have the option to choose alternative operating systems or browsers.
  • The use of multiple browsers is seen as a burden by some, while others find it necessary for different use cases or to avoid data collection.
  • Microsoft's ownership of the OS is seen as sufficient for data collection, making the need to push Edge unnecessary.
  • The quality of Bing as a search engine is questioned, with some wondering what Microsoft hopes to gain from promoting it.
  • Edge is considered a decent browser, but its association with Microsoft's aggressive tactics taints its reputation.