How the .NET Foundation kerfuffle became a brouhaha (robmensching.com)

Article summary

The author of the WiX Toolset, a .NET Foundation project, describes their negative experience with the foundation, including a lack of communication and trust issues. The foundation unexpectedly moved the WiX Toolset to their GitHub Enterprise without permission, which the author considers a betrayal of trust. The author had previously refused to grant the foundation admin access due to trust concerns. The incident has led to a re-evaluation of the .NET Foundation's role and trustworthiness.

Main themes

• NET Foundation trust issues
• Ecosystem modernization
• Pay-to-win concerns
• Documentation and guidance
• Cross-platform development
• Trust and community relations

What commenters say

• The .NET ecosystem has improved significantly with .NET Core, offering a modern and free alternative to the old .NET Framework.
• The .NET ecosystem is perceived as pay-to-win, with many useful tools and libraries requiring payment, which can be a barrier for some developers.
• The lack of clear guidance and unclear documentation in the .NET ecosystem can lead to confusion and frustration for developers.
• Some developers have had positive experiences with the .NET ecosystem, finding it to be modern and well-supported.
• The integration of Xamarin into the .NET ecosystem is seen as a strength, allowing for cross-platform development.
• The .NET Foundation's actions have led to a loss of trust among some developers, who question the foundation's role and motivations.