news.volyx.in

Surveilance bill rushed through Australian parliament in 24 hours (tutanota.com)

508 points by ghoda · 1849 days ago · 361 comments on HN

Article summary

The Australian government has passed a surveillance bill that allows police to hack devices, collect or delete data, and take over social media accounts without sufficient safeguards. The bill was rushed through parliament in less than 24 hours, with critics arguing that it enables law enforcement to investigate any serious crime without adequate judicial oversight. Companies are required to comply with warrants, and refusal to do so can result in imprisonment. The bill has been criticized for undermining the right to privacy and potentially leading to abuse of power.

Main themes

  • surveillance state
  • erosion of civil liberties
  • authoritarianism
  • democracy and its flaws
  • privacy and human rights
  • migration and brain drain

What commenters say

  • Voting is not an effective solution to the problem of surveillance, and more drastic actions such as leaving the country may be necessary.
  • The surveillance bill is a sign of a larger trend towards authoritarianism and erosion of civil liberties.
  • Democracy can lead to dumb laws and a tyranny of the majority, where the interests of the intelligent and capable are ignored.
  • The idea that the bottom 51% of the population will always have more influence than the top 51% is not necessarily true, and other factors such as education and wealth can play a significant role.
  • A brain drain may not be an effective solution to the problem of surveillance, as it could lead to even dumber laws being passed.
  • The surveillance bill is a threat to human rights and privacy, and its passage is a sign of a failed system.
  • Leaving the country may be a viable option for individuals who value their privacy and freedom, but it does not address the underlying problem.
  • The concept of democracy is flawed, and alternative systems such as a republic may be more effective in protecting individual rights and preventing the abuse of power.