news.volyx.in

FOSS app removed from the Play Store for linking to the project's website (github.com)

853 points by timothyaveni · 1868 days ago · 278 comments on HN

Article summary

A FOSS app, Language Transfer, was removed from the Google Play Store because it linked to the project's website, which has a way to contribute funds to the project. The app's developer had previously removed links to the project's Patreon page to comply with Google's policies. The developer is now trying to find a way to comply with Google's policies while still allowing users to support the project. The app has since been reinstated.

Main themes

  • Google Play Store policies
  • open-source development
  • app store dominance
  • alternative app stores
  • progressive web apps
  • machine learning research
  • censorship on YouTube
  • legislation and regulation

What commenters say

  • Google's policies on app store payments are overly restrictive and stifle developer freedom.
  • The removal of the app from the Play Store is an example of Google's abuse of power and disregard for open-source projects.
  • Alternative app stores, such as F-Droid, offer more freedom and flexibility for developers.
  • Google's actions may drive developers to create progressive web apps instead of native apps.
  • Some commenters argue that Google's actions are not entirely negative and that the company has made significant contributions to various fields, such as machine learning research.
  • Others believe that Google's positive contributions do not excuse its questionable behavior in other areas, such as app store policies and censorship on YouTube.
  • The issue highlights the need for more open and inclusive app store policies and the importance of supporting open-source projects.
  • Legislation, such as the Open App Markets Act, may be necessary to address the issue of app store dominance and ensure a more level playing field for developers.