Internet of Snitches (puri.sm)

Article summary

The article discusses the concept of an 'Internet of Snitches' where devices and apps scan for evidence of crime, potentially infringing on personal privacy. Apple's recent announcement to scan iPhone photos for child sexual abuse material is seen as a step towards this reality. The article argues that this sets a precedent for other companies to follow, potentially leading to a broader range of scanning for various types of content. This could result in a loss of control and ownership over personal devices and data.

Main themes

• Internet of Snitches
• client-side scanning
• personal privacy
• surveillance and censorship
• free and open-source software
• government regulation
• international perspectives on surveillance
• balance between safety and freedom

What commenters say

• Some argue that Apple's move towards client-side scanning is a legitimate step towards preventing child abuse, but others see it as a threat to personal privacy.
• The implementation of client-side scanning could lead to false positives and ruined lives, especially if vendors are pressured by governments to expand the scope of their scans.
• There is a concern that the slippery slope argument against increased surveillance is not a fallacy, but a realistic prediction based on historical trends.
• Others propose that government regulation is necessary to limit the ability of companies to implement client-side scanning, while some argue that true control and ownership over devices can only be achieved through the use of free and open-source software and hardware.
• The discussion around surveillance and censorship is often US-centric, and looking to other countries can provide evidence for the potential benefits and drawbacks of increased surveillance.
• Some argue that increased surveillance, such as through CCTV cameras, can lead to safer cities, but others disagree and point to the potential for abuse and erosion of civil liberties.
• The use of 'dumb' TVs and other devices that do not connect to the internet is seen as a way to opt-out of the 'Internet of Snitches', but such options are becoming increasingly rare.
• There is a need for a balanced approach to surveillance and censorship, taking into account both the potential benefits and the risks to personal freedom and privacy.