news.volyx.in

Tesla’s $16k Quote for a $700 Fix Is Why Right to Repair Matters (thedrive.com)

907 points by samizdis · 1901 days ago · 539 comments on HN

Article summary

A Tesla Model 3 owner was quoted $16,000 by Tesla to replace a damaged battery pack, but a third-party repair shop was able to fix the issue for $700. The problem was caused by road debris damaging the car's cooling system, and the repair involved replacing a molded hose barb with a threaded fitting. The incident highlights the high cost of repairs for Tesla vehicles and the importance of the right to repair. The owner's insurance policy did not cover the damage, and Tesla initially planned to keep the damaged battery pack, but eventually agreed to return it after the owner cited a consumer protection law.

Main themes

  • Right to Repair
  • Tesla Repair Costs
  • Consumer Protection
  • Automotive Industry
  • Independent Repair Shops
  • OEM Parts Availability

What commenters say

  • The $700 repair cost is still too high and mostly profit for the repair shop.
  • Tesla's high repair costs and restrictive policies are a major drawback for customers.
  • The right to repair is essential for consumers to have options for fixing their vehicles without being forced to rely on the manufacturer.
  • The quality of Tesla's vehicles and repair services is questionable and comparable to other manufacturers.
  • The use of non-OEM parts and repairs can be safe and effective, but may not be accepted by the manufacturer.
  • The lack of transparency and availability of OEM parts from Tesla makes it difficult for independent repair shops to compete.
  • The incident highlights the need for better consumer protection laws and regulations to prevent manufacturers from taking advantage of customers.
  • The cost of the repair is not just about the parts, but also the labor and expertise required to fix the complex systems in modern vehicles.