news.volyx.in

No More Movies (jayriverlong.github.io)

605 points by jeffreyrogers · 1908 days ago · 564 comments on HN

Article summary

The article's content is not available, but the discussion revolves around the idea that finding exceptional movies is rare and that the quality of writing is a key factor in making a great film. Commenters share their thoughts on what makes a movie stand out, with some emphasizing the importance of writing, while others argue that other elements like acting, editing, and cinematography are equally crucial. The conversation also touches on the subjective nature of film appreciation and the role of personal taste in evaluating movies. The rarity of exceptional movies is attributed to the difficulty of consistently producing high-quality content.

Main themes

  • importance of writing in film
  • subjective nature of film appreciation
  • role of personal taste in evaluating movies
  • rarity of exceptional movies
  • challenge of producing high-quality content
  • balance between technical aspects and storytelling in filmmaking

What commenters say

  • The quality of writing is the most important factor in making a great film, and it is rare to find exceptional writers.
  • Other elements like acting, editing, and cinematography are equally important in making a great movie, and it is not just about the writing.
  • A good movie does not have to be cerebral or have a complex plot, but it should be able to evoke emotions and tell a compelling story.
  • The subjective nature of film appreciation means that what one person considers a great movie, another person may not, and personal taste plays a significant role in evaluating films.
  • Even with competent filmmaking, a movie can be ruined by poor writing, acting, or other technical aspects.
  • Some movies can be enjoyable despite their flaws, and it is possible for a film to be salvaged by strong performances or other redeeming qualities.
  • The rarity of exceptional movies is due to the challenge of consistently producing high-quality content, and it is not just about the writing or any one aspect of filmmaking.
  • The importance of storytelling and emotional resonance in films is often overlooked in favor of analyzing plot details and technical aspects.