news.volyx.in

I refused to become an FBI informant, the government put me on the no fly list (aclu.org)

1206 points by jbegley · 1999 days ago · 487 comments on HN

Article summary

A man was approached by the FBI under false pretenses and asked to become an informant, which he refused. He was subsequently put on the No Fly List, causing significant disruption to his life. The man, with the help of the ACLU, brought a lawsuit against the government and was eventually removed from the list. The incident highlights concerns about government overreach and the use of watchlists to coerce individuals.

Main themes

  • Government overreach
  • No Fly List
  • FBI tactics
  • Coercion and intimidation
  • Due process and accountability
  • Surveillance and watchlists

What commenters say

  • Requesting a lawyer during questioning can help protect one's rights, but may not be effective in all situations, such as when the goal is coercion rather than conviction.
  • The FBI's tactics, including using false pretenses and intimidation, can be damaging to individuals and their families.
  • The No Fly List can be used as a tool for coercion, and its use raises concerns about due process and the balance of power between the government and citizens.
  • In situations where the government is trying to coerce someone into becoming an informant, having a lawyer present may not be enough to prevent negative consequences.
  • The incident highlights the importance of being aware of one's rights and the potential risks of interacting with law enforcement, even for people who are not accused of a crime.
  • The use of watchlists and other forms of surveillance can have a disproportionate impact on certain communities, including Muslim Americans.
  • The government's actions in this case demonstrate a lack of accountability and transparency, and raise concerns about the potential for abuse of power.