news.volyx.in

On Trouser Pockets (sambleckley.com)

769 points by diiq · 2269 days ago · 390 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the lack of innovation in clothing design, particularly in trouser pockets, which have remained largely unchanged despite the evolution of technology and lifestyles. The author argues that traditional pockets are often impractical and uncomfortable, and proposes a new design for pockets that prioritizes accessibility and comfort. The author created a pair of trousers with unusual pockets and found them to be more practical and comfortable than traditional designs. The article also touches on the history of clothing design and the influence of mass production on fashion trends.

Main themes

  • clothing design innovation
  • pocket functionality
  • fashion and identity
  • class and cultural norms
  • practicality vs. aesthetics
  • mass production and fashion trends

What commenters say

  • Some commenters felt that the article's criticism of cargo pants was unfair and classist, implying that people who wear them are pretending to have a certain occupation or lifestyle.
  • Others defended the practicality and comfort of cargo pants, citing their own experiences wearing them for work or daily activities.
  • The article's author was seen as having a negative tone towards cargo pants, which some felt was unjustified and dismissive of people who wear them for legitimate reasons.
  • There was disagreement over whether the proposed new pocket design was truly innovative or just a variation on existing designs, such as those found in cargo pants.
  • Some commenters pointed out that the article's focus on office wear and formal clothing was narrow and ignored the needs and preferences of people who work in different fields or have different lifestyles.
  • The discussion also touched on the broader themes of fashion, identity, and cultural norms, with some commenters arguing that clothing choices are often influenced by social and cultural factors rather than just practical considerations.