news.volyx.in

Orthodox Privilege (paulgraham.com)

610 points by razin · 2272 days ago · 910 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses the concept of orthodox privilege, but its content is not available. However, the comments reveal a discussion about the emergence of two orthodoxies or conventions in America, which are often referred to as 'anti-PC' and 'woke'. These two groups are seen as having different worldviews and values, with some commenters arguing that they are both driven by a desire for power and control. The discussion also touches on the polarization of society and the role of science and education in shaping our understanding of the world.

Main themes

  • Orthodox Privilege
  • Polarization of Society
  • Politicization of Science
  • Social Justice and Identity Politics
  • Free Speech and Open Debate
  • Power and Control

What commenters say

  • The emergence of two orthodoxies in America, 'anti-PC' and 'woke', is driven by a desire for power and control.
  • The 'woke' movement is seen as a form of social justice, but its means and methods are often criticized as illiberal and unjust.
  • Science has become politicized, with some arguing that it is being used as a tool to bludgeon opponents and silence dissent.
  • The polarization of society is driven by the extreme elements of both the 'anti-PC' and 'woke' groups, which are often at odds with more moderate and centrist views.
  • The concept of 'woke' is seen as a form of orthodoxy that is being imposed on society, with those who disagree being labeled as 'transphobic' or 'bigoted'.
  • The 'anti-PC' group is seen as a reaction against the perceived excesses of the 'woke' movement, with some arguing that it is a necessary corrective to the erosion of free speech and open debate.
  • The role of education and science in shaping our understanding of the world is seen as crucial, but also vulnerable to politicization and ideological manipulation.