news.volyx.in

Linux Mint drops Ubuntu Snap packages (lwn.net)

1106 points by jonquark · 2279 days ago · 523 comments on HN

Article summary

The Linux Mint project has decided to prevent Ubuntu Snap packages from being installed through the APT package-management system without user consent. This move is due to concerns over user choice and software freedom. Ubuntu's parent company, Canonical, is open to finding a solution, but has its own interests to consider. The issue arose when Ubuntu started distributing software in parallel to APT using Snap, a self-contained package-deployment system.

Main themes

  • Snap packages
  • Software freedom
  • User choice
  • Package management
  • Linux distributions
  • Canonical's strategy

What commenters say

  • Some argue that Canonical's decision to use Snap packages is a gross abuse of power and undermines user choice.
  • Others believe that Snap packages provide a convenient way to install and update software, but the implementation has significant drawbacks.
  • The use of Snap packages is seen as a threat to software freedom and the open-source community.
  • Some commenters suggest that Linux Mint should use alternative package managers, such as Flatpak, or build their own packages from Debian source code.
  • There are concerns about the security and stability of Snap packages, particularly with regards to auto-updates and sandboxing.
  • The decision to use Snap packages is viewed as a strategic move by Canonical to control Linux software distribution.
  • Some users are considering switching to alternative Linux distributions, such as Pop!_OS, due to the Snap package issue.