Why we won’t be supporting Sign in with Apple (blog.anylist.com)

Article summary

The company behind AnyList, a grocery list app, has decided not to support Sign in with Apple due to concerns over user experience, customer support, and collaboration. They argue that Sign in with Apple introduces several problems, including the potential for unused and unchecked iCloud email addresses and the complications of the 'Hide My Email' feature. The company is also removing Facebook Login from their app, citing similar concerns and a desire to prioritize user privacy. This decision is in response to Apple's new rule requiring many apps to support Sign in with Apple by June 30th.

Main themes

• Sign in with Apple
• user privacy
• customer support
• app login systems
• Facebook Login
• data collection

What commenters say

• The article's arguments against Sign in with Apple are seen as contrived and motivated by a desire to collect user email addresses.
• Sign in with Apple is a positive step forward for user privacy, even if it means some apps will no longer require Facebook or Google accounts to log in.
• The company's decision not to support Sign in with Apple is a win for Apple and end-user privacy, as it eliminates the use of Facebook's login feature.
• Some commenters have had negative experiences with apps that only offer Facebook or Google login options, and appreciate the ability to use email and password instead.
• The use of Sign in with Apple and other third-party login systems can be seen as a way for companies to offload the burden of identity verification to someone else.
• The article's claims about prioritizing user privacy are questioned by some commenters, who point out that the company has been known to automatically subscribe users to marketing lists without consent.
• The removal of Facebook Login from the app is seen as a positive step, but some commenters are skeptical of the company's motivations and worry about the potential consequences for user data.
• The discussion highlights the trade-offs between convenience, security, and privacy in app login systems, with different commenters prioritizing these factors differently.