news.volyx.in

Let's guess what Google requires in 14 days or they kill our extension (blog.pushbullet.com)

1915 points by cimnine · 2337 days ago · 788 comments on HN

Article summary

The Pushbullet Chrome extension is at risk of being removed from the Chrome Web Store due to non-compliance with Google's Program Policies, specifically the 'Use of Permissions' section. The extension's developers have made changes to reduce the permissions requested, but these changes were rejected by Google without further guidance. The developers are now trying to guess what changes are required to avoid removal. The extension has over 1 million users and a 4.5-star rating, making its potential removal a significant issue for its developers and users.

Main themes

  • Chrome Web Store policies
  • extension removal
  • user privacy
  • developer frustration
  • alternative browsers
  • Google's motivations
  • ecosystem control

What commenters say

  • Google's lack of clear guidance on required changes is frustrating and unhelpful for developers.
  • The removal of the Pushbullet extension could be motivated by Google's own interests, such as promoting its Messages App.
  • Switching to alternative browsers like Firefox or Edge could be a viable solution for users who rely on the Pushbullet extension.
  • Mozilla's dependence on Google funding may compromise its ability to make independent decisions, potentially leading to similar issues with extensions in the future.
  • The Chrome Web Store's policies and review process are overly restrictive and may stifle innovation and user choice.
  • The issue highlights the need for better communication and support from Google for developers and users alike.
  • Some users are willing to switch to alternative browsers or solutions, such as kdeconnect or gsconnect, to maintain functionality and avoid Google's ecosystem.
  • Google's actions may be seen as an attempt to exert control over the ecosystem and limit user choice, rather than prioritizing user privacy and security.