news.volyx.in

Disney claims anyone using a Twitter hashtag is agreeing to their terms of use (twitter.com)

888 points by slg · 2353 days ago · 353 comments on HN

Article summary

Disney claims that anyone using the Twitter hashtag #MayThe4th agrees to their terms of use, allowing them to use the message and account name in all media. This claim has sparked controversy and discussion about the validity and potential abuse of such a policy. The terms of use are linked in a tweet from Disney+, and a clarification tweet states that the policy only applies to replies to the original tweet. The move has raised concerns about copyright and trademark law, as well as the power dynamics between large corporations and individual users.

Main themes

  • copyright and trademark law
  • corporate power dynamics
  • social media policy
  • user consent and consideration
  • IP law reform
  • abuse of power

What commenters say

  • The policy is unlikely to hold up in court due to its overly broad and abusive nature.
  • Disney's move is a strategic attempt to protect themselves from potential lawsuits, but it may ultimately backfire.
  • The requirement of consideration in contracts means that Disney cannot unilaterally impose their terms of use on Twitter users.
  • A collective backlash or political action may be necessary to challenge Disney's policy and promote IP law reform.
  • The policy highlights the imbalance of power between large corporations and individual users, making it difficult for individuals to challenge or opt out.
  • Some argue that Disney's policy is a legitimate attempt to manage their intellectual property and protect their brand.
  • Others believe that the policy is an overreach and an attempt to exploit users' content without permission or compensation.