news.volyx.in

Mapping Coronavirus, Responsibly (esri.com)

681 points by three14 · 2418 days ago · 166 comments on HN

Article summary

The article discusses responsible mapping of the coronavirus outbreak, including guidelines for visualizations and interpreting data. It highlights the importance of clear and accurate communication in data visualization. The article also touches on the use of 3D visualizations and their potential to be misleading. The main goal is to provide a framework for creating informative and responsible maps of the outbreak.

Main themes

  • responsible mapping
  • data visualization
  • coronavirus outbreak
  • geopolitics
  • Tufte's principles
  • clear communication
  • map accuracy
  • censorship and market considerations

What commenters say

  • Data visualization should prioritize clarity over visual impact.
  • Edward Tufte's principles of visual communication are still relevant and useful today, but may be overemphasized.
  • Maps can be misleading or inaccurate if not created responsibly, particularly when it comes to geopolitical issues like Taiwan's status.
  • The inclusion of Taiwan in a map of coronavirus cases in China may be a deliberate choice to avoid censorship or to sell products in the Chinese market.
  • Good data visualization tools can help create effective and accurate visual representations of information.
  • The choice of visualization type depends on the audience and purpose, with some types being more suitable for detailed study and others for quick overview.
  • Some commentators disagree on the value of Tufte's work, with some finding it helpful and others considering it overrated.
  • The question of whether Taiwan should be included in a map of China is a contentious issue with significant implications for public health policy and geopolitical relations.