news.volyx.in

Ultimate Electronics (ultimateelectronicsbook.com)

624 points by tosh · 2432 days ago · 85 comments on HN

Article summary

The article presents an interactive electronics book called Ultimate Electronics, which provides a comprehensive introduction to electronics and circuit design. The book covers various topics, including conceptual foundations, linear direct current electronics, and active logic. It also features interactive examples and simulations to help learners understand complex concepts. The book is designed for electronics hobbyists and electrical engineering students.

Main themes

  • Electronics Education
  • Practical Experience
  • Theoretical Knowledge
  • Circuit Design
  • Energy and Fields
  • Electronic Engineering vs. Design
  • Learning Resources

What commenters say

  • Formal education in electronics may not provide sufficient practical experience, and hands-on tinkering is essential for building proficiency.
  • Theoretical knowledge of electronics is not necessarily required to design and build circuits, and many designers rely on empirical knowledge and rules of thumb.
  • Electronics design can be approached from different levels, ranging from following established recipes to understanding the underlying theory and designing from scratch.
  • The importance of understanding fields and energy in electronics cannot be overstated, and it is crucial to recognize that energy is contained in the fields, not just the charges.
  • Some commenters argue that the book's approach may be too theoretical and may discourage beginners, while others appreciate the comprehensive introduction to electronics.
  • There is a distinction between electronic engineering and the art and craft of electronic design, with the former focusing on mathematical modeling and analysis, and the latter emphasizing practical skills and rules of thumb.
  • Many commenters recommend alternative resources, such as The Art of Electronics, for learning electronics design and theory.