news.volyx.in

California Attorney General delays .org sale (domainnamewire.com)

543 points by bbatsell · 2445 days ago · 40 comments on HN

Article summary

The California Attorney General has delayed the sale of the .org domain registry to Ethos Capital by requesting extensive documentation from ICANN, which may lead to a two-month delay in the approval process. The Attorney General's office is seeking information on the removal of price caps on .org domain names and the decision-making process behind the sale. ICANN has been asked to provide unredacted information, which may become public record. The delay may impact the sale of the registry, which is valued at $1.135 billion.

Main themes

  • ICANN governance
  • domain name pricing
  • non-profit regulation
  • private equity investment
  • internet governance
  • conflict of interest

What commenters say

  • The sale of the .org registry to a private equity firm may lead to increased prices for domain owners and potentially harm non-profit organizations.
  • The removal of price caps on .org domain names was a necessary step to allow the registry to compete with other top-level domains.
  • The California Attorney General's investigation may uncover conflicts of interest or other issues that could impact the sale of the registry.
  • The sale of the .org registry is not necessarily dead, as the private equity firm may still be able to negotiate a deal with ICANN.
  • The focus on price caps may be a distraction from the larger issue of ICANN's role in regulating domain names and its potential conflicts of interest.
  • The .org registry should be operated as a non-profit entity, with any surplus funds used to improve the service rather than being sold to a private equity firm.
  • The sale of the .org registry could potentially give a private equity firm control over who gets .org domains, which could be a concern for freedom of speech and access to information.