news.volyx.in

Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation (bbc.com)

803 points by schappim · 2521 days ago · 721 comments on HN

Article summary

Sweden has dropped its investigation into a rape allegation against Julian Assange, citing weakened evidence due to the long period of time since the events in question. Assange has denied the allegations, which date back to 2010. The decision means there will be no competing extradition request to the one from the US, where Assange faces 18 criminal charges. Assange is currently being held in a London prison ahead of his extradition hearing.

Main themes

  • Julian Assange
  • Rape Investigation
  • Extradition
  • US Charges
  • Statute of Limitations
  • Memory and Testimony

What commenters say

  • The Swedish prosecution's decision to drop the investigation is due to the weakening of evidence over time, particularly eyewitness testimony.
  • The concept of statute of limitations is flawed as it prioritizes closure over justice, and can prevent prosecution of crimes even when evidence is still available.
  • The idea that a person's memory of an event can be reliably used as evidence after many years is questionable, and can be subject to distortion and loss of details.
  • The use of condom is a crucial aspect of consent in sexual intercourse, and secretly removing it without the partner's knowledge can be considered rape.
  • Ex post facto laws are generally frowned upon and are prohibited in some jurisdictions, but their application can be complex and nuanced.
  • The reliability of eyewitness testimony is limited, and can be influenced by various factors, including the passage of time and external suggestions.
  • The distinction between consensual and non-consensual sex acts can be complex, and requires careful consideration of the circumstances and communication between partners.