news.volyx.in

Amtrak Could Turn a Profit for the First Time (wbur.org)

484 points by jonbaer · 2523 days ago · 434 comments on HN

Article summary

Amtrak is on track to break even on its passenger railroad service next year for the first time in the company's nearly 50-year history. The company reported an operating revenue of $3.3 billion for fiscal year 2019, a 3.6% increase over the last year, and reduced operating losses by close to $400 million. Amtrak's president and CEO attributes the improvement to employees' dedication to the company's mission and statutory obligation. The company plans to prioritize urban corridors over cross-country routes and offer more differentiated products on the same line.

Main themes

  • Amtrak profitability
  • rail transportation
  • infrastructure investment
  • urban planning
  • public transit

What commenters say

  • The US is too large for efficient rail transportation, making it difficult for Amtrak to turn a profit.
  • Amtrak's focus on urban corridors is a good strategy, given the high demand for transportation in these areas.
  • The company's profitability is not the primary concern, as transportation infrastructure is a public good that provides economic benefits beyond direct revenue.
  • Some argue that Amtrak is a natural monopoly and deserves subsidies, while others believe that it should be subject to market forces and competition.
  • The comparison between Amtrak's subsidies and those for highways is unfair, as highways carry a much larger volume of passengers and goods.
  • Investing in rail infrastructure could have long-term economic benefits, such as revitalizing smaller communities and reducing traffic congestion.
  • Others argue that the money spent on Amtrak could be better spent on other forms of transportation, such as buses or highways, which may be more efficient or cost-effective.