news.volyx.in

Apple Hides Taiwan Flag in Hong Kong (blog.emojipedia.org)

1456 points by pulisse · 2566 days ago · 686 comments on HN

Article summary

Apple has removed the Taiwan flag emoji from the emoji keyboard on iOS devices in Hong Kong, although the emoji is still accessible through other means. This change is seen as a compromise between completely banning the emoji and fully supporting it. The move is part of a broader effort by China to pressure global companies into referring to Taiwan as part of China. The change affects all iPhones purchased in Hong Kong, as well as international iPhones with the region set to Hong Kong.

Main themes

  • censorship
  • China-Taiwan relations
  • corporate compliance
  • global politics
  • emoji usage
  • regional restrictions

What commenters say

  • The removal of the Taiwan flag emoji is a form of censorship that sets a dangerous precedent for future restrictions on free speech.
  • The decision to hide the emoji is a compromise that is better than banning it altogether, and users can still access it through other means.
  • The issue highlights the tension between corporate interests and individual freedoms, and the need for companies to balance their business goals with social responsibility.
  • The ability of China to exert control over global companies like Apple is a concerning sign of its growing influence and power.
  • Some argue that the focus on emoji usage is petty and trivial, while others see it as a symptom of a broader pattern of censorship and control.
  • The debate over the Taiwan flag emoji reflects deeper disagreements about the status of Taiwan and its relationship to China, with some arguing that it is a sovereign state and others disputing this claim.
  • The use of slippery slope arguments to criticize the removal of the emoji is seen as a fallacy by some, who argue that each restriction should be evaluated on its own merits rather than as part of a larger trend.
  • Others argue that the slippery slope argument is valid, and that the gradual erosion of freedoms can have significant consequences over time.