news.volyx.in

Advertising Is a Cancer on Society (jacek.zlydach.pl)

692 points by TeMPOraL · 2637 days ago · 640 comments on HN

Article summary

The article argues that advertising has become a destructive force in modern society, comparing it to a cancer that consumes resources and destroys trust. It claims that advertising has moved beyond its original purpose of informing people about products and services, and now focuses on manipulation and exploitation. The article lists various symptoms of this disease, including privacy violations, health-related privacy violations, and the degradation of online services. The author suggests that the advertising industry has become a major contributor to the problems of modern society.

Main themes

  • advertising as a destructive force
  • privacy violations
  • exploitation of personal data
  • degradation of online services
  • alternative business models

What commenters say

  • Getting rid of advertising would likely lead to the shutdown of major companies like Google and Facebook, which rely heavily on ad revenue to provide valuable services to the public. Some argue that alternative business models, such as subscription-based services, could support these companies without the need for advertising. Others believe that the value provided by these companies is not worth the cost of advertising and the exploitation of personal data. A few commenters suggest that the web existed and functioned well before the rise of Google and Facebook, and that alternative models like Wikipedia and Linux have proven that it is possible to provide valuable services without relying on advertising. Some argue that advertising is not inherently bad, but that the current state of the industry has become corrupt and exploitative. Others propose that a peer-to-peer or paid model could support a high-quality search engine without the need for advertising. There is disagreement over whether the benefits of advertising, such as supporting free services, outweigh the costs, including the exploitation of personal data and the degradation of online services.